Cakes & Special Orders
Custom Creations & Sweet Celebrations
Step into a world where your sweetest dreams take shape with Genuine Ice Cream's cakes and special orders. Whether it's a uniquely decorated ice cream cake, a bespoke pie, or custom-flavored pints, we're here to turn your vision into a delicious reality. Let us be a part of your celebrations, crafting custom treats that make your special moments even more memorable.
Ice Cream Cakes
Our ice cream cakes are made with two layers of our super premium ice cream, an Oreo cookie crust, whipped cream frosting and sprinkles. We do not do any writing on our cakes. We offer cakes in two sizes: 6 inch ($36) and 9 inch ($48). Fill out the form below to place an order for your next celebration or just a Tuesday night. All custom cakes are made to order and must be placed one week in advance. We also stock ice cream cakes in our shop that are available on a first come, first serve basis.
Special Orders
We offer special orders for pick up! We can make ice cream cakes (use form above to order), seasonal ice cream pies, custom flavors, special order pints or quarts. Most items need at least seven business days notice. Pick up from our retail space at 605 W. Peach St, Unit 101. Fill out the form so we can better understand what you're looking for.